Marathon of the Mind

DEPARTMENT OF
MANAGEMENT INFORMATION SYSTEMS &
COMPUTER INFORMATION SYSTEMS


debate contest


Complex and interesting questions are often raised at the interface of Artificial Intelligence and Ethics about the essence of humanity, spirituality, and corporate social responsibility.  An example of such controversy can be found in the intense debate raised by such emerging and controversial concepts as robotic slavery and robots’ rights. As we push the frontiers of Artificial Intelligence, creation of robots with human-like intelligence and an ability to display social behaviors, learning capabilities, and adaptation to the environment is just a matter of time.  The purpose of this debate is to explore the potential existence and resolution of ethical dilemmas in a society where the line between man and machine becomes increasingly thin and perhaps tenuous.

The topic for the debate contest is: 

Resolved that:  Intelligent robots impose an ethical burden on society far too greater than any benefits that they can be expected to provide

Contestants are required to take one of the two positions [For or Against the resolution]  on the topic and present their arguments in support of the position they have taken as clearly, thoroughly, and systematically as possible.   

    • Each contestant will be given a maximum time of 10 minutes for the presentation.
    • Contestants will be separated from the audience at the beginning of the contest, but will be allowed to join the audience after their participation in the contest. 
    • No projectors or visual aids are permitted.
    • Contestants may use notes for reference, but are discouraged to directly read from a prepared speech.
    • Contestants’ ability to articulate and support their positions using rhetorical and logical argumentation skills will be the primary criterion of judging their performance.  Other criteria include originality, background research, and demonstration of critical thinking skills.  
    • The debate contest is tentatively scheduled for Thursday, October 16, 2008 between 6 PM and 9 PM.
    • Additional updates will be provided to each of the registered contestants individually.

    <<Back to Announcement Page